Mamma Lucia: Discover the Best New York Style Pizza in Wexford, PA
Mamma Lucia, located in Wexford, PA, is a celebrated pizzeria known for its exceptional New York-style pizza. Patrons rave about the perfectly cooked crust that boasts a satisfying undercarriage and a delectable flavor. The marinated mushrooms and crab pizza have received special mentions for their taste and quality. While prices may be slightly higher than typical pizza joints, customers unanimously agree that the culinary experience is worth every penny. Mamma Lucia also offers garlic knots, although some noted a need for extra attention to their texture. Overall, it's a must-visit destination for pizza lovers in the northern suburbs of Pittsburgh.
Photos & Gallery
Popular Menu Items
Round Neapolitan Pepperoni Pizza
Garlic Knots and Pepperoni Pizza
Slice of Pizza
Pizza and Garlic Knots
Philly Steak Sandwich
Meat Lovers Pizza
Large 16 Sicilian Pizza
Italian Sub
Garlic Rolls
Calzone
Mamma Lucia: Reviews & Ratings
A little more expensive than your average pizza joint, but well worth it. Their New York style pizza is delicious. Try the marinated mushrooms!
Best pizza in the north hills. Good undercarriage, no flop Crust is cooked to perfection. Solid place to get a few slices and not have to order an entire pizza.
Pizza was very good crispy and it was very filling. My dad got the crab pizza and said the crab was juicy. We also got the garlic knots and it came with a side of sauce it was amazing the knots on the other hand were a bit hard I would definitely go back again
Fantastic pizza and quite possibly the best in the entire northern suburbs of Pittsburgh. I grew up eating their pizza at the Northway Mall back in the day. Highly recommended, you won't be disappointed. Would of got 5 stars, but their price point is a touch on the higher side, but still worth it.
Great neapolitan pizza with pepperoni. They're Sicilian is probably top in the area but you have to tell them to cook it a little bit longer the normal. This time we got the pepperoni round and it seemed like it wasn't as good as normal and wasn't as crispy even though it just came out of the oven as we always order it.
Sicilian with a salad on a Sunday. Have you ever had a moment when you taste something so good and you are transported to your childhood and you remember what the joy of eating a pizza in a pizzeria was like as an eight year old? I am just hoping you can and I hope you will find it at Mama Lucia’s like I did. The pizza was so fresh and the dough so soft, sauce so balanced, cheese so good and the pepperoni just the perfect resistance. Little crispy bits on the edges. Just a great Pizza! Oh and the salad was good too.
The pizza by the slice option is convenient. It’s already cooked, they add the additional toppings you want(if any) and heat it in the oven. Pizza was good, loved the garlic knots.
Location
-
11978 Perry Hwy #408, Wexford, PA 15090, United States Hotline: +1 724-799-8918
Discovering Mamma Lucia: A Slice Above the Rest
Nestled in Wexford, PA, Mamma Lucia has quickly become a favorite among pizza enthusiasts in the northern suburbs of Pittsburgh. This charming little pizza joint, located at 11978 Perry Hwy #408, offers a delightful array of options that cater to both traditionalists and adventurous eaters alike.
Mamma Lucia is not just another pizzeria; it's a haven for those who appreciate quality ingredients and authentic flavors. The menu boasts a variety of delicious offerings, but the highlight undoubtedly lies in their New York-style pizza. Customers rave about its excellence, often mentioning the perfectly cooked crust that provides an excellent undercarriage—showcasing no flop, just the right amount of crispy finish. The pizza's base is a canvas that supports a palette of mouthwatering toppings, including the praised marinated mushrooms, which add an extra layer of flavor that shouldn’t be missed.
In addition to their stellar pies, Mamma Lucia also presents unique choices such as the crab pizza, which has received notable praise for its juicy crab meat—an innovative twist that leaves diners craving more. The garlic knots served with marinara sauce make for a perfect starter or side, though some customers have noted that they can be a tad on the firmer side. Regardless, the overall experience and satisfaction derived from their dishes is hard to overlook.
While it is true that Mamma Lucia may sit at a slightly higher price point compared to your typical pizza joint, patrons agree that the quality of the food makes every penny worth it. The consistent commendations from customers like 'Lawn King' affirm this sentiment, declaring it possibly the best pizza in all of northern Pittsburgh—with roots tracing back to fond childhood memories at the Northway Mall.
In conclusion, Mamma Lucia stands out not only for its flavorful and well-prepared dishes but also for its commitment to quality. Whether you're looking for slices to share or a whole pizza to satisfy a craving, you won't be disappointed by what this gem has to offer. With a warm inviting atmosphere and remarkable culinary creations, Mamma Lucia is undoubtedly a place worth visiting.
Contact Information:
Address: 11978 Perry Hwy #408, Wexford, PA 15090, United States
Phone: +1 724-799-8918
- Accessibility
- Has wheelchair-accessible car park
- Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
- Has wheelchair-accessible seating
- Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
- Service options
- Has outdoor seating
- Offers takeaway
- Serves dine-in
- Payments
- Accepts credit cards
- Accepts debit cards
- Accepts NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards